Earlier this week, I mentioned being unsettled by this article stating that gay marriage is the “wrong issue.” What I should have said is that I take massive issue with it. The author seems to insinuate that not only should gays have better things to do with their time than stick up for their own rights, but we are also all of the same political beliefs and voting party, which must be so narrowly focused on one issue that it can’t possibly muster the resources to multitask.
I will not feel guilty for wanting equal rights.
If you are gay and don’t want to get married, fine. But there are plenty of us who would, and I will not sit idly as you create a greedy kid in the candy store allusion or a smokescreen to hide that this fight has implications on all of our rights — gay and straight, and well beyond marriage.
Plenty of homosexuals are disenfranchised by our government, and it may not incapacitate everyone, but there are certainly those whom it hurts greatly. It may be financially or it may sever families and relationships altogether. How often do we hear stories about people not allowed to see or receive information about their dying spouses, fighting over estates with families, not able to have families in the first place, or, especially at the holidays, not having the person they love accepted into the rest of their family?
Legal marriage means more than a ring on a finger and the next step to kids, a dog, and a white picket fence. It means tax benefits, better access to family health plans, co-parenting privileges, automatic preference for guardianship and medical decision-making authority, as well as protection under divorce and separation laws.
But let’s go back to that picket fence. Why does marriage itself matter to me? I don’t plan on having partners go in and out of my life. I want to have that dedication. I want to grow old with someone. I want my children to know I’m dedicated to that person. I want them to have a family unit they can count on, and I want that unit protected under the law.
There are many things I plan to do in my life from which I’ll derive happiness; environmental work, certainly more activism — at least as much as I’m allowed. But one thing I know I will do one day is have children. What amazes me is that in a world that is this interconnected, we often have to stretch to find role models. If the family unit is the foundation of Christianity, why can’t we allow committed gay couples and their children to live equally with the same sense of family and to see other families out there like their own?
When I raise my children, who will most likely be straight themselves, I want them to have a sense of family. I want them to look to their parents as people who are lovingly dedicated to one another. And I want them to see role models for what a relationship should be like. I want them to see the power of what two people can build together and I don’t want them to ever have to wonder if their dads’ commitment means less than those of their classmates’ parents. Or why their government insinuates that it means something less. I don’t want any wiggle room for anyone to say that we aren’t equal.
My kids will know better because I will raise them to recognize that there are many kinds of love, but I also want them to know that our country is better for accepting the commitment of everyone who loves someone else. That is how I hope to cherish someone someday, and that is why these rights are important to me. And no, the government certainly doesn’t validate my feelings for another person or my commitment to them, but it does protect it. It is the importance of valuing all families under the law, regardless of title.
Wanting all of this is not an effort to be like straight married couples. It’s an effort to say that my commitment is equivalent and deserving of equal treatment to that of a straight couple in the eyes of the law. How many years were gays painted as promiscuous or pedophiles? To continually accuse us of deleterious alternative lifestyles without an equal opportunity for commitment under the law is ridiculous.
Now, why do marriage rights matter? Because there are real repercussions when the government states that it’s okay to not look at me or any other gay person as an equal. It’s serving up a legal slap across the face that says I’m more disposable or not a real person.
Again, it’s about role models. It’s time for our country’s leaders to take a stand and say “it’s okay to be gay.” Not just for the kid in middle America thinking about killing himself because he’s just figured out who he is — and who he is also happens to be a kid living in an unaccepting conservative community. Certainly that’s reason enough. But our country prides itself on being a world leader, and for too long we’ve fallen to ridiculous, Puritanical fear of anything outside of an institution that frankly hasn’t existed that long. We preach civil rights across the globe; we can’t forget that gays are killed regularly by governments that believe how they were born is a sin.
And let’s talk about here in our country. Hate crimes in the U.S. are up this year from 1,265 in 2007 – and those are just the acts that make the reports and get classified as hate crimes. If that doesn’t make you angry or hit home, please watch this video again. And maybe apathy is part of it, because if we the modern gays aren’t being beaten to death (or can ignore those who are) in our cushy cities, we don’t notice we’re still playing out their archetypes of second class citizenry. We forget there are still so many people afraid to come out at work, afraid to share their partner with the people they spend 8-10 hours along side of every day.
Have you people not had someone scream “faggot” at you or follow you down the street? Do you want to continue to have to think twice before holding hands with your partner? Don’t forget how that feels; it’s what a society that draws lines between our rights and theirs condones. And if we don’t stay on top of these hate campaigns, which is what Prop 8 is, we’re going to continue suffering this state by state “death by a thousand cuts,” where we allow people to vote on a minority issue that should not be allowed to reach a vote in the first place. This is not just someone saying “no, you don’t have the right to marry.” This is society saying it’s okay to be a bigot. And if you don’t think it holds that weight, you’re kidding yourself.
So what rights are we talking about here? We are dealing with a legal patchwork that doesn’t even remotely work in our favor when examined from afar. Domestic partnership laws vary and can offer very little for a gay couple. There is more than a semantic difference between a civil union and a marriage. We’re not talking about a few rights, we’re talking about 1049 federal and state benefits, and ones that you don’t want to be negotiating when there’s an emergency. From taxation — being able to transfer assets and wealth to your partner without tax penalties; to health insurance, which might be guaranteed in a state where you have a civil union but might count for nothing if you’re on vacation somewhere else; to social security survivor benefits — same sex couples are eligible only for earnings of the survivor, not the couple; to emergency decisions — partners in civil unions can only make medical decisions for their partner in the registered state; to child/spousal support — same sex couples receive no benefits of financial obligation if the union dissolves. Nevermind the hassle of filing state returns jointly and federal returns as single.
You don’t enter a relationship (much less a marriage) for yourself. You’re in it for the other person and all that you bring to each other’s lives. It’s a commitment to that person to share whatever is yours as theirs. And this is why we must work for federal protection and lay the groundwork to overturn the DOMA.
I cannot say it better than Christie Keith, who wrote a phenomenal testimony which I encourage all of you to read (I know, I’m asking you to do a lot of clicking and reading today). She finishes the article with these words and I’ll leave you the same way:
So stop. Just stop telling us not to be angry or hurt or so emotional. This happened to us. It damages us. It reminds us of our pain, which many of us put behind us at great personal cost. I have lost dozens of friends to suicide, alcoholism, and depression. I’ve lost friends to gay bashing, and to a disease that ran unchecked and ignored because it “only” killed fags. I live in San Francisco, and there are huge parts of this city I wouldn’t feel safe holding my girlfriend’s hand. Do you not understand what it’s like to live like that?
If you can’t stand with us, at least have the grace to stop giving us advice, advocating our silence, lecturing us about our behavior, or telling us who and what we are. What we do as a movement now is in our hands, and those of our allies. If you’re not one of them, shut up and get out of the way.